BRECKENRIDGE — Breckenridge’s village manager has been a member of the village Zoning Board of Appeals since 2017, and the village website lists him there today. Michigan’s zoning law says village employees may not serve on that board. Separately, the village cut its planning commission to seven members in December, keeping three seats for village officials; state law caps such members at one-third.

The zoning appeals board

On July 24, 2017, the council voted “to appoint the following individuals to serve on the Zoning Board of Appeals Board. Jerry Loyselle, Nick Lux, Roy Shankel, Charles Seeley and Manager Jeff Ostrander.” (minutes, July 24, 2017) The village’s Zoning Board page lists the same five members today (village Zoning Board page).

The Michigan Zoning Enabling Act says: “An employee or contractor of the legislative body may not serve as a member of the zoning board of appeals.” (MCL 125.3601) The same section allows one member of the council on the board, as long as that member does not chair it. Charles Seeley is the village president.

A zoning appeals board hears appeals of zoning decisions and requests for variances. In Breckenridge, the village lists Ostrander as its zoning administrator, the official who makes those decisions in the first place (village office page).

The planning commission

At its Dec. 8, 2025, meeting, the planning commission took up a change to its own ordinance. The minutes say: “Currently, the Planning Commission sits at 9 members. Due to attendance and occasional quorum issues, it has been proposed to reduce the number of members to 7. This would reduce the number of Village residents on the commission to 4 instead of 6. The other 3 members remain the Village President, one Administrator Official of the village, and one member of Council.” (planning commission minutes, Dec. 8, 2025)

Members raised the concern themselves. “Discussion was had about whether or not 3 out of 7 members coming from the village office could potentially skew votes or opinions,” the minutes say. They also record why the change was proposed: at least once that year, “a meeting was cancelled due to not having a quorum.” The commission sent the change to the council 6–1; Chairman Tim Schaub voted no. Two seats whose terms ended in February would not be refilled.

The council approved “the Planning Commission Ordinance as amended” on Dec. 22 (minutes, Dec. 22, 2025). By the March 9, 2026, meeting, the commission listed seven members, without Schaub, and elected council member Teresa Burt as chair (minutes, Jan. 12, 2026, March 9, 2026).

Michigan’s planning law allows a village’s president, council members and chief administrative official to sit on its planning commission as ex officio members, but “not more than 1/3 of the members of the planning commission may be ex officio members” (MCL 125.3815). Three of seven is 43%. On a nine-member commission, three was exactly one-third.

Who holds what

  • Jeff Ostrander (Thomas J. Ostrander in village resolutions): village manager; the village lists him as chief administrative officer, zoning administrator, street administrator and police administrator (village office page), and as DPW/water/sewer supervisor (village contact page); planning commissioner (planning commission page); zoning appeals board member; and, since Dec. 22, 2025, the village’s member on the county’s Central Dispatch board (minutes, Dec. 22, 2025).
  • Charles “Chuck” Seeley: village president since at least January 2016, the earliest posted minutes; planning commissioner; zoning appeals board member. He was re-elected Nov. 3 without an opponent, 359 votes to 12 write-ins, in unofficial results (Gratiot County results).
  • Teresa Burt: council member and, since March, planning commission chair.

What we do not know yet

  • The exact text of the planning commission ordinance as amended in December.
  • Whether the Zoning Board of Appeals has met or decided any case since 2017, and who sat on it when it did.
  • Whether the village attorney reviewed either board’s membership against state law.

Corrections and responses are welcome.